This is the second part of a three-step control group experiment attempting to get the Hummingbird Bakery’s vanilla cupcakes recipe to work in the high altitude environment of Denver.
Recall that I determined that I could do three things to adjust the recipe:
- Add flour, to strengthen the recipe’s batter and prevent it from collapsing into a puddle of goop during the cooling process.
- Decrease the amount of sugar, since sugar interferes with egg protein’s coagulation and requires more heat to set. Alternatively, I could just bake the cupcakes at a higher temperature.
- Decrease the amount of baking powder in the recipe, to slow down and decrease the batter’s rise.
Last week, I added a tablespoon of flour to the recipe to mixed success. The extra flour strengthened the recipe’s batter and contained the cake’s rise — that is, I didn’t end up puddles of goop spilling over the pan’s edges. However, as the cupcakes cooled, they sank in the center, creating a crater-like appearance.
This week, I decided to decrease the amount of sugar in the recipe. According to the oft-cited Pie in the Sky: Successful Baking at High-Altitudes, the reduction of a little sugar may add sufficient strength and eliminate the need to add additional flour. Sugar has a lot of functions in the baking process, but the most relevant in my case are the following two:
- Sugar slows down the coagulation of egg proteins.
This means that batter containing a high amount of sugar needs more heat in order to set. The less sugar in a batter, the more quickly the batter will set in the oven.
Note that the unaltered Hummingbird vanilla cupcakes recipe produced puddles of liquidy, sticky goop. That means that the batter never really fully set in the oven. Reducing the sugar could potentially fix this problem.
- Sugar increases the final product’s tenderness.
Sugar interferes with the ability of gluten stands to join together; the more sugar present, the weaker the gluten strands and the more tender the product. Some sugar is therefore necessary to achieve a tender texture. However, recall that liquids evaporate more quickly at high altitudes; such evaporation leaves excess concentrations of sugar in a batter, which can then boil up and easily overflow.
This is especially relevant in my case since a constant issue I seem to have are the cupcakes overflowing from their allotted space and off the sides of the pan. The recipe might be using excess concentrations of sugar, causing this overflow. Decreasing the sugar could potentially stop this.
Without further ado, here is the amended ingredients list (changes are in bold):
- 1 cup all-purpose flour
- a “scant” 3/4 cup sugar minus 1 tablespoon of sugar
- 1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
- a pinch of salt
- 3 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 1/2 cup whole milk
- 1 egg
- 1/4 tspn vanilla extract
This is what the cupcakes looked like when I pulled them out of the oven:
I thought that reducing the sugar was supposed to stop the batter from overspreading into puddle-like appearances! Reducing the sugar seems to be a REGRESSION from increasing the flour. At least the cupcakes with the extra flour were kept contained in their little cupcake spaces. These seem more akin to the unaltered Hummingbird Bakery recipe results. ESPECIALLY when they cooled:
The centers sunk in, creating craters in the cupcakes and completing the “puddle of goop” appearance that I’ve become so familiar with:
Getting them out of the pan was another matter entirely. Unsurprisingly, the parts that had overflowed were really stuck onto the metal pan:
The remaining part of the cupcake — that is, the batter that actually remained in the allotted cupcake space — seemed to lack structure entirely. They crushed easily when I tried to pull the cake out of the pan, squeezing together in a weird, moist, sticky mess. The batter appeared to not have set fully. I thought reducing the sugar was supposed to remediate this problem by allowing the batter to set faster with less heat?!
And what about the taste? To be honest, they tasted severely undercooked and bland — reducing even just a tablespoon of sugar affected the cupcakes’ flavor intensely. The final product tasted too flour-y and ultimately, flavorless.
Sigh. Never again will I mess with the cupcake’s sugar content.
Well, it’s good to know, I guess? It seems that even increasing flour and decreasing sugar still didn’t really do a whole lot to contain the over-rising of the original recipe. I have a sneaking suspicion that the final recipe will contain additional flour, the same amount of sugar, and a significantly decreased amount of baking powder. I guess we’ll find out in the next post though — maybe a decrease in baking powder is all I really need.